Too Little Butter Spread Across Too Much Bread

buy cheap doxycycline online cheapest synthroid prices xanax without prescription cheap prozac tablets cheap tramadol acomplia zithromax pharmacy tramadol without a prescription phentermine pills buy generic accutane where to buy cialis cheap zoloft online doxycycline prices cheap generic phentermine nexium online cheap cheap synthroid tablets acomplia online nexium pills buy cheap propecia buy plavix buy diazepam without prescription accutane online stores accutane cheap cheap generic viagra clomid without prescription cheap plavix buy bactrim without prescription tramadol online phentermine without prescription buy synthroid diazepam online stores discount diazepam nexium online stores bactrim online stores order diazepam purchase lasix online purchase lorazepam bactrim prescription buy cheap tramadol zithromax online cheap acomplia generic phentermine plavix for sale cheap plavix tablets cheap tramadol tablets pharmacy lasix lasix sale pharmacy diazepam buy doxycycline accutane prices buy cheap phentermine lasix prices buy cheap nexium synthroid for sale plavix discount buy doxycycline cheap lowest price alprazolam cheap lorazepam online nexium cheap cheap generic cialis discount propecia pharmacy prozac soma discount soma online buy generic flagyl discount nexium cheapest tramadol prices discount viagra levitra generic buy accutane cheap synthroid pharmacy where to buy phentermine acomplia pills viagra sale bactrim pharmacy buy accutane without prescription lowest price acomplia buy lorazepam cheap buy phentermine without prescription diazepam for sale cheapest clomid valium prices buy prozac online tramadol sale clomid online synthroid cheap cheap alprazolam online order soma online buy zithromax phentermine no prescription where to buy lorazepam accutane online where to buy bactrim propecia cheap cheapest valium prices pharmacy lorazepam bactrim for sale price of soma buy cialis order bactrim online lorazepam without prescription zoloft without prescription lowest price diazepam pharmacy clomid cheap propecia buy levitra cheap purchase soma online purchase prozac order zithromax valium no prescription valium prozac prices nexium generic zoloft cheap cheap generic prozac order doxycycline online diazepam pills levitra accutane no prescription buy lorazepam tramadol prices online doxycycline where to buy synthroid buy alprazolam online alprazolam prescription zoloft buy cheap flagyl online zithromax pills online valium acomplia cheap plavix pills cheap zithromax online levitra online stores lorazepam pills order flagyl online doxycycline prescription cheap lorazepam buy acomplia discount acomplia cheapest prozac prices alprazolam without a prescription online synthroid cheap phentermine tablets alprazolam order clomid online cheapest diazepam prices zoloft for sale viagra pharmacy buy cheap lorazepam online clomid online cheap pharmacy tramadol buy cheap soma purchase clomid online cheap doxycycline purchase prozac online purchase cialis flagyl prescription diazepam prices viagra online stores accutane prozac pharmacy bactrim generic buy zoloft without prescription lowest price flagyl clomid pills buy clomid online cialis pharmacy pharmacy phentermine price of clomid buy acomplia online price of prozac phentermine online tramadol buy lasix online levitra without prescription buy cheap xanax online cheapest propecia prices cheapest acomplia prices buy lorazepam online cheap generic xanax accutane without a prescription synthroid without prescription order plavix flagyl without a prescription buy generic clomid lowest price lorazepam order soma order zoloft online propecia sale synthroid discount pharmacy cialis price of lasix prozac pills tramadol without prescription valium pharmacy purchase zoloft online buy cheap lorazepam accutane for sale lowest price clomid levitra no prescription synthroid sale nexium prices lowest price nexium generic lorazepam purchase synthroid xanax online cheap purchase bactrim cheapest alprazolam synthroid generic cheap xanax cheap generic acomplia buy cheap lasix online accutane pharmacy alprazolam pills cheap valium online lowest price cialis plavix generic buy levitra online tramadol online stores buy cheap nexium online zithromax lorazepam online stores acomplia no prescription lorazepam cheap bactrim no prescription buy plavix online lasix generic purchase clomid buy cheap zoloft online buy generic xanax doxycycline online cheap lorazepam online cheap cialis online cheap zithromax for sale generic lasix cheapest synthroid generic nexium purchase phentermine online prozac generic order prozac online clomid prices where to buy tramadol price of phentermine phentermine prescription lowest price propecia cialis online stores discount plavix cheap diazepam soma generic cheapest viagra prices cheapest bactrim prices buy cheap flagyl lorazepam pharmacy buy diazepam online propecia discount buy valium buy zithromax without prescription buy generic tramadol order levitra valium discount nexium online discount doxycycline bactrim cheap propecia prices plavix prices online nexium clomid generic synthroid buy cheap prozac online lasix online stores buy cheap valium online cheap xanax tablets xanax without a prescription buy soma online cheap phentermine online where to buy prozac where to buy alprazolam buy cheap plavix online order phentermine generic clomid buy tramadol cheap prozac cheap propecia tablets generic xanax purchase zithromax levitra online purchase viagra propecia generic generic synthroid buy cheap alprazolam online where to buy propecia acomplia without prescription cheapest diazepam order lorazepam xanax discount where to buy zithromax cheap diazepam tablets price of cialis cheap generic lasix order flagyl buy clomid without prescription diazepam online cheap order accutane zithromax without prescription doxycycline cheap lasix online cheap cheapest plavix alprazolam online buy cheap clomid online buy generic zithromax levitra for sale buy cheap acomplia doxycycline online stores purchase flagyl online nexium generic plavix pharmacy nexium price of alprazolam purchase nexium online buy generic cialis cheap flagyl tablets buy cheap bactrim online buy alprazolam cheap soma sale buy generic synthroid phentermine sale plavix pharmacy buy viagra online xanax purchase cialis online pharmacy flagyl alprazolam no prescription cheapest bactrim buy cialis online clomid sale flagyl online stores tramadol pills propecia online cheap lowest price tramadol cheap valium tablets price of viagra clomid no prescription synthroid pills order doxycycline nexium sale order cialis price of zithromax buy nexium cheap alprazolam for sale discount valium buy generic acomplia generic tramadol plavix without a prescription online clomid cheapest lorazepam prices lasix without a prescription order levitra online cheap cialis online online soma cialis no prescription buy propecia zoloft discount lowest price lasix cheap prozac phentermine generic cheapest levitra levitra pharmacy clomid pharmacy bactrim prices acomplia online cheap where to buy diazepam cheap generic levitra accutane sale tramadol discount cheapest doxycycline purchase acomplia online accutane online cheap cheap generic tramadol price of bactrim order lorazepam online order xanax online purchase levitra flagyl online valium for sale cialis plavix sale cheap levitra tablets price of zoloft purchase viagra online cheap generic zoloft flagyl discount prozac prescription soma pharmacy propecia order propecia online price of flagyl online levitra price of doxycycline bactrim propecia without a prescription acomplia prescription order synthroid zoloft online cheap flagyl sale buy synthroid cheap buy lasix without prescription zoloft without a prescription alprazolam sale buy tramadol without prescription prozac without a prescription flagyl generic buy propecia online cialis prices purchase lasix cheapest nexium purchase diazepam buy lorazepam without prescription buy cialis cheap lorazepam no prescription where to buy accutane xanax online zithromax discount prozac discount synthroid prescription lowest price bactrim discount zithromax accutane generic buy generic bactrim order valium online buy generic lorazepam cheap generic flagyl where to buy zoloft purchase accutane online discount phentermine plavix cheap zithromax cheap cheap generic lorazepam viagra cheap xanax online purchase bactrim online generic valium propecia online stores flagyl pharmacy lowest price valium buy synthroid without prescription cheap viagra online buy cheap lasix cheap doxycycline tablets levitra cheap online alprazolam diazepam pharmacy cheapest nexium prices purchase acomplia xanax pharmacy propecia pharmacy cheap accutane online valium without prescription cheap alprazolam purchase propecia purchase diazepam online cheapest phentermine prices generic zoloft order tramadol clomid online stores plavix no prescription price of synthroid cheap generic propecia cheapest tramadol order alprazolam online buy alprazolam without prescription buy cheap cialis discount levitra where to buy valium cheap prozac online cheap generic soma lorazepam generic buy flagyl cheap price of propecia lowest price soma order acomplia online lowest price viagra buy doxycycline without prescription cheap zithromax tablets flagyl no prescription diazepam without a prescription cheap levitra online prozac online cheap levitra without a prescription buy generic doxycycline buy prozac cheap phentermine for sale buy bactrim cheap pharmacy zithromax cheapest flagyl where to buy flagyl acomplia online stores buy lasix cheap buy cheap propecia online cheap soma cheapest accutane prices pharmacy alprazolam lasix pharmacy cheap zithromax viagra prescription zithromax without a prescription online accutane cheap lasix online acomplia generic cheap flagyl cheap clomid tablets order lasix online cheapest alprazolam prices buy nexium buy cheap clomid synthroid without a prescription accutane pills buy clomid diazepam sale bactrim sale lorazepam cheap doxycycline online valium pills buy soma cheap buy lasix phentermine online stores buy synthroid online online lorazepam lasix no prescription buy generic propecia xanax for sale cheapest zoloft prices buy phentermine cheap plavix online cheap bactrim cheap viagra tablets viagra without prescription cheap generic diazepam buy zoloft cheap order accutane online cheapest soma prices clomid cheap viagra prices phentermine cheap nexium pharmacy discount synthroid lorazepam prices buy xanax flagyl cheap cheap generic doxycycline buy cheap levitra prozac no prescription buy zithromax cheap discount lasix discount tramadol prozac without prescription discount cialis cheap lasix soma prices online phentermine buy propecia without prescription cheap diazepam online online diazepam plavix online cheap order bactrim where to buy soma cheapest xanax prices buy cheap xanax xanax prices cheap clomid online prozac online lowest price zithromax online bactrim cheapest cialis valium online stores synthroid online stores zoloft prices generic acomplia xanax cheap diazepam discount viagra online purchase tramadol online valium without a prescription order zithromax online doxycycline no prescription tramadol clomid for sale pharmacy soma viagra discount synthroid online cheap purchase propecia online viagra online cheap cheap valium cialis without a prescription discount prozac lasix online levitra online cheap cheap soma online buy levitra without prescription buy flagyl online buy cheap zithromax online acomplia discount where to buy plavix cheapest soma soma online cheap nexium without a prescription purchase alprazolam zoloft online tramadol no prescription cheap phentermine online cialis zoloft online stores phentermine online lasix pills valium sale cheap bactrim online clomid prescription generic viagra levitra pills purchase xanax online buy bactrim pharmacy plavix buy cheap diazepam accutane prescription buy cheap diazepam online buy nexium online cheap lorazepam tablets cheap alprazolam tablets price of valium buy cheap synthroid online discount bactrim lasix without prescription generic alprazolam flagyl without prescription online xanax viagra no prescription generic zithromax levitra prices generic cialis buy cheap phentermine online buy clomid cheap buy xanax cheap cialis online buy generic viagra doxycycline discount order clomid online propecia cheap plavix online purchase valium online cheap zoloft generic propecia lorazepam discount buy cheap soma online buy cheap prozac phentermine prices xanax pills online prozac prozac online stores acomplia pharmacy acomplia prices buy viagra lowest price doxycycline cheap acomplia online cheapest levitra prices buy cheap doxycycline buy cheap tramadol online propecia prescription zithromax generic buy tramadol price of plavix lowest price phentermine prozac sale buy alprazolam cheap generic clomid cheapest accutane discount soma purchase synthroid online buy generic plavix doxycycline generic purchase plavix xanax prescription valium generic bactrim online cheap purchase lorazepam online buy xanax online alprazolam online stores price of acomplia zoloft prescription soma pills generic levitra cheap synthroid discount zoloft alprazolam pharmacy viagra cheap cheap accutane cheap generic bactrim buy phentermine online buy flagyl buy levitra cheapest acomplia buy generic phentermine price of tramadol buy cheap zithromax cheap lasix tablets buy plavix cheap nexium discount tramadol pharmacy purchase accutane phentermine online cheap buy cheap acomplia online cialis cheap lasix for sale cheap flagyl online nexium no prescription cheapest lasix prices pharmacy xanax buy tramadol online alprazolam without prescription buy zithromax online order nexium viagra generic buy generic valium where to buy acomplia acomplia without a prescription buy cheap viagra pharmacy levitra order phentermine online buy flagyl without prescription buy accutane buy cheap alprazolam purchase zithromax online lowest price prozac lowest price accutane doxycycline sale bactrim without a prescription alprazolam online cheap cheap generic zithromax pharmacy bactrim levitra discount cheapest plavix prices buy cheap synthroid purchase doxycycline online buy cialis without prescription generic bactrim buy zoloft online synthroid prices propecia online cheap acomplia tablets buy cheap zoloft doxycycline pharmacy cheapest prozac cheap viagra cheap nexium online price of diazepam cheap generic plavix cialis prescription xanax online stores soma prescription plavix without prescription soma for sale lowest price zoloft cheapest zithromax prices cheapest zithromax buy generic alprazolam lorazepam for sale alprazolam generic cialis for sale cheap tramadol online cheapest cialis prices synthroid online order tramadol online buy viagra without prescription order viagra online zithromax no prescription order plavix online flagyl pills cheap cialis tablets cheap clomid diazepam generic buy generic nexium purchase alprazolam online flagyl propecia pills viagra without a prescription propecia for sale cheap cialis flagyl for sale prozac cheap diazepam without prescription zoloft sale order viagra accutane discount doxycycline for sale valium prescription lorazepam online bactrim discount cheapest valium order zoloft alprazolam cheap zoloft generic buy prozac without prescription purchase phentermine online lasix online flagyl cheapest propecia lorazepam sale order synthroid online valium online cheap purchase doxycycline cialis discount lowest price plavix purchase xanax zithromax prices pharmacy propecia buy prozac doxycycline cheap generic synthroid purchase tramadol pharmacy viagra cheapest xanax soma cheap generic accutane soma no prescription order lasix price of nexium buy valium without prescription buy cheap accutane xanax generic doxycycline without a prescription buy cheap levitra online synthroid no prescription cheapest phentermine valium online buy generic levitra cheapest doxycycline prices prozac for sale plavix online stores purchase levitra online lorazepam without a prescription zithromax online stores lasix prescription buy cheap cialis online buy valium online pharmacy zoloft pharmacy doxycycline price of accutane cheapest clomid prices clomid without a prescription valium cheap acomplia sale bactrim without prescription zoloft pharmacy levitra prescription tramadol cheap buy viagra cheap cheapest zoloft buy soma cheap propecia online flagyl online cheap cheap generic alprazolam cheapest lorazepam buy diazepam purchase soma soma without a prescription buy generic diazepam buy cheap viagra online cheap levitra cheap generic valium purchase zoloft order prozac plavix zoloft no prescription discount xanax pharmacy valium clomid discount cheap accutane tablets accutane without prescription soma without prescription soma cheap propecia no prescription propecia without prescription zithromax prescription pharmacy accutane cheapest viagra buy bactrim online diazepam cheap order acomplia buy generic zoloft order valium cheap soma tablets xanax sale buy generic soma viagra for sale cheap zoloft tablets lorazepam prescription diazepam prescription price of xanax nexium without prescription order diazepam online discount flagyl where to buy lasix pharmacy synthroid cheap nexium tablets buy cheap valium generic prozac buy xanax without prescription zithromax sale cheapest lasix bactrim pills lasix where to buy xanax diazepam online order xanax doxycycline pills purchase nexium phentermine pharmacy cialis pills buy doxycycline online buy soma without prescription lowest price levitra clomid alprazolam discount buy phentermine buy generic lasix buy acomplia without prescription cheap bactrim tablets discount lorazepam zithromax online cheap buy diazepam cheap generic soma order propecia generic diazepam order nexium online tramadol online cheap purchase plavix online lasix discount online viagra alprazolam prices phentermine discount where to buy levitra acomplia for sale soma online stores buy cheap bactrim bactrim online price of levitra generic accutane buy cheap accutane online order cialis online nexium for sale where to buy nexium price of lorazepam buy propecia cheap doxycycline online levitra sale cheap nexium cheapest flagyl prices cialis without prescription buy nexium without prescription discount accutane where to buy viagra zoloft pills where to buy doxycycline tramadol for sale buy zoloft tramadol generic cialis sale where to buy clomid online zoloft cheap synthroid online buy accutane online nexium prescription purchase flagyl flagyl prices buy generic prozac discount alprazolam diazepam no prescription buy cheap plavix viagra pills phentermine without a prescription buy valium cheap generic flagyl cialis generic online zithromax cheap generic nexium doxycycline without prescription lasix cheap online plavix buy plavix without prescription generic doxycycline plavix prescription buy acomplia cheap diazepam xanax no prescription discount clomid purchase valium online acomplia lowest price xanax tramadol prescription pharmacy acomplia lowest price synthroid order alprazolam

Unlike many of my family members, I cannot recite every word from every conversation I hear or every movie I see. Indeed, I find both skills annoying because verifying the asserted memory is often pointless or inconvenient. But, one line I remember from the movie version of the Fellowship of the Ring was when the rapidly aging hobbit Bilbo Baggins confides in his young friend and heir, Frodo Baggins, that he feels like “too little butter spread across too much bread.”

That seems to be a cause of the demise of many wonderful organizations. They lose focus to ego driven goal setting, they lose effectiveness by squandering the good will accumulated by years of toil and hardship, and in the end they continue as increasingly fainter, shallower, and quieter organizations until finally they are gone.

This seemed to happen in the 2000 elections when the mighty PAC (“political action committee”), Campaign for Working Families, founded by Gary L. Bauer, was turned over to a caretaker director while Bauer ran for the presidency. His stated goal was to inject the abortion debate into the political thought of the time, but his PAC had already been very successful raising funds, and in elections, that was enough to raise the issue.

During his campaign for the presidency, he tried to use the contributors and mailing lists of the PAC in his campaign. I remember telling one of the many staffers that telephoned me to obtain a contribution that Bauer needed to stand in line for PAC money like every other candidate. But, clever as I thought that was, the staffer did not understand what I meant. It was a short conversation. I lost all interest even before Bauer had to install a glass door on his office to ward off accusations of fraternization with one of this campaign staffers, because the PAC was no longer focused on its mission, and Bauer’s chances in the election were never credible. I have never again supported Bauer’s work.

The same thing seems to be happening to Jay Sekulow’s American Center for Law and Justice. Originally founded as a para-church ministry to act as a “Christian public interest” law firm, the organization seems to have tired of its focus on legal issues and is spreading shallowly like spilled water in all directions. One day the ACLJ is writing briefs, but the next it is circulating petitions to support Israel’s struggle to survive (which needs to be done but by somebody else with that focus), or issuing “news of the day” analyses about what is being taught by university professors (with a thin or non-existent explanation of the data used to found the conclusions reached). ACLJ’s website is becoming a cacophony of issues, many of which are not before any court, or not before any court in any case in which ACLJ appears to have entered an appearance.

Is Sekulow primping for a run for national office? That would be a shame. Continuing Legal Education authors and speakers often mention him when they are name dropping about cases involving constitutional questions relating to the Establishment Clause. But, will he forfeit that distinction and reputation and attempt to become recognized as a news commentator or even a foreign policy advisor? Is Sekulow’s ego forcing him to joust at windmills instead of slaying the dragons that hound Christians in school districts, counties and cities? Like Bauer, will he fail, or at least be set back, because he became too little spread too far?

My fear is that just as Bauer probably felt that his contribution to the national debate was growing too slowly or reaching too few people, causing him to imagine he could by the force of his personality influence a national presidential election, Sekulow may have conceded to himself that he can only take so much ground in the Establishment Clause and similar cases. From that conclusion, has he begun to cast about for new issues and new sources of support to propel himself to another “plane of existence?”

The work of the ACLJ is too valuable to abandon. Just as the impoverished must have the Legal Services Corporation (“legal aid”), Christians desperately need a similar organization on watch and on call. Most local churches simply do not have the resources, much less the expertise or will, to fight these critical trench warfare battles without the ACLJ. Bauer did not get it. His PAC was, and still could be, vital in the battle to keep the abortion debate alive so that it might reach a just conclusion. Even if Roe v. Wade was abandoned as national policy tomorrow, there would still be decades of legislative work and litigation to be done, but Bauer seemed to abandon it all in favor of his personal run for the presidency. If Sekulow makes similar poor choices, the ensuing loss of ACLJ will likely be a culture war disaster of the first magnitude resulting in the further erosion of freedoms for Christians.

Two Sides of Religious Freedom: Does Ecclesiastical Privilege Balance Curtailment of Free Speech?

The free expression of religious speech has received another setback from a Des Moines federal court when it squelched a Prison Fellowship program in a state prison. The decision is nonsensical; inmates who had no fear about breaking criminal laws would have no difficulty refusing to participate in a Prison Fellowship program.

The other side of the coin is “ecclesiastical privilege,” the body of law that prevents government and courts from intruding into church governance. Two recent court decisions demonstrate the breadth of the “flipside” of the Establishment Clause’s present abusive application. The “other side” of the Establishment Clause might even be a fair offset to decisions like the one in Des Moines. But is it?

In a case involving a United Methodist church, a case which can be read on the Oklahoma State Courts Network (at 2006 OK CIV APP 79), the defamation claim of the youth minister was dismissed under the doctrine. In a Texas case which also involved a Methodist church, the Third Circuit Texas appellate court also dismissed the defamation claim of a youth minister.

In the Oklahoma case, the senior minister told a member of the congregation, a young person, that the reason for the youth minister’s termination was because the youth minister was “questioning his sexuality.” The allegation was shocking, and the fact that a senior minister felt free to communicate it to a “young member,” as reported in the opinion, was equally shocking.

In the Texas case, the youth minister’s dating life was subjected to scrutiny, as well as accusations that he was putting his arm around some “girls” in the church. Apparently the rumors were sufficiently troubling that two more senior ministers were considering terminating him. One of the ministers took notes of the meeting between them, and the youth minister found the notes on the photocopy machine. Such a lapse, leaving the notes on the copy machine, also seems shocking and unprofessional. Like the Oklahoma court, the Texas court dismissed the defamation claim.

Other than a sad commentary on the lack of professionalism in the salaried clergy, and other than a sad commentary on the abrupt and callous handling of youth ministers, which are typically younger, less experienced, and new to ministry, both churches and their ministers had free reign without civil law accountability. Maybe this is as it should be in churches, in order to fully effectuate the Establishment Clause. Most business people would like to have the same shield.

These published appellate opinions have shed some light on personnel problems that churches should address differently, and probably with greater professionalism as well as more compassion. Also, in both instances, there was the availability of denominational resources, some of which should be devoted to Human Resources management and training.

The “right” of the matter cannot be determined in either case merely from the appellate opinions, but what is clear is that enormous resources in legal fees were probably wasted by both sides, tithed resources, no doubt, that could have been better spent solving the problems. If someone is indeed not cut out for the ministry, the amount spent in legal fees would still have been less than severance or retraining resources for youth ministers unready or unqualified for the mission.

Afraid of God in Liberty, Texas?

Liberty Elementary School in Keller, Texas, used a graphic of the new Liberty nickel on the cover of its yearbook this year. But to make sure they didn’t offend atheists, they deleted the words “In God We Trust” from the graphic. Then, to make sure they didn’t offend believers, they included an “In God We Trust” sticker with each book for those who wanted to add our nation’s motto back onto the coin.

Ironically, the motto was deleted from the yearbook cover because its use “might create an issue,” the superintendent said. Keller is a suburb of Fort Worth. Here’s the Star-Telegram’s report.

Here’s some interesting info from the Department of the Treasury on the “In God We Trust” motto, which has been used on U.S. coins and currency since the Civil War days. A century later, the U.S. Congress voted in 1956 to make “In God We Trust” the official national motto of the United States.

Even in “Liberty,” Texas.

Afghan Believer Released; Muslims Chant “Death to Christians!”

Abdul Rahman, the Afghan man who faced a possible death sentence by beheading for converting from Islam to Christianity, has been released. Muslims, chanting “Death to Christians!” took to the streets to protest Rahman’s freedom. Rahman was turned into authorities by his own family, who are among the Afghan Muslims who seek Rahman’s execution for the crime of following Christ.

Rahman has gone into hiding, and Italy has offered him asylum. More news from the Associated Baptist Press here. The ABP reports says at least two other Afghan Christians remain in jail under circumstances similar to Rahman’s ordeal.

Two-hundred and eighty-four U.S. military have been killed in Afghanistan since the U.S.-led invasion of that country in 2001. The U.S. has 18,000 troops stationed in Afghanistan. The most recent U.S. death happened earlier today, when Taliban insurgents attacked the U.S. base there.

The Afghan constitution, which was drafted and adopted after the Taliban was ousted in 2001, declares Islam the supreme law of the land, and Islamic law calls for the execution of Muslims who abandon the religion. Tony Perkins of the Family Research Council, an organization closely linked to James Dobson, criticized the Bush administration’s foreign policy for failing to make religious freedom in Afghanistan and elsewhere a top priority. Quoted in the ABP article linked above, Perkins said:

Simply dismissing the charges based upon lack of evidence does not sufficiently address the lack of religious freedom in Afghanistan. As the United States continues its work in Afghanistan and Iraq, it is vital that the Bush administration secure a clear understanding of religious freedom from these new governments. Abdul Rahman’s imprisonment has revealed a major fault in our foreign policy.

Higher Education Attacks Jeffersonian Democracy

Le Moyne College is a Roman Catholic institution of higher learning governed by the Jesuits and in its mission statement, claims to be called to “promote a more just society.” Even as a non-Catholic, I have always been intrigued by the Jesuits and not a little awed by their history and accomplishments. That makes the present controversy impossible to fathom.

CNSNews.com reported that LeMoyne College dismissed a graduate student from the graduate school of education because he wrote a paper favoring corporal punishment, spanking, as part of a program of discipline in an “ideal learning environment.” Litigation followed and a New York state court held that LeMoyne College violated its own handbook by failing to allow the student to appeal from the adverse decision. LeMoyne College has decided to appeal, according to the news report. By the way, the paper earned an “A-“ and the student’s grade point average was above 3.7, so the dismissal could not be cloaked as academic failure.

The Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (“FIRE”) has posted the results of their work in the matter to their website, which included the decision of the NY court in favor of the student and ordering the school to follow its own handbook. The opinion is only three pages long and does not mention the separation of church and state or distinguish LeMoyne College as a private religious institution, but merely ruled on generic contract principles. FIRE’s letters and the college’s original dismissal letter are also posted.

This is my first chance to review FIRE’s work and it was impressive in this case to this point. For many years I have followed the work of Jay Sekulow, Esq. and even his opponents publicly recognize the quality of his work. FIRE may be playing a niche role with similar competence.

The private church run school was clearly wrong. But, are we happy to see a successful intervention by a secular court, even on secular contract grounds? However, without seeing the briefing filed by the college, it is impossible to know whether the school claimed its decision was based on religious views.

Equally troubling is that UCLA, clearly a leading educational institution in this nation supported by taxpayer funds, plans legal action against an alumnus that founded an organization targeting “political radicalism on campus,” according to CNSNews.com, and presses its views through a website that identified “radical professors” and then rated them according to their views and efforts to convert their students to those views. UCLA’s cease and desist letter was based on trade mark violations. The website dropped all trade marks and disclaimed official affiliation with UCLA, but a UCLA spokesperson indicated legal action was still being designed to silence the website. The lesson to be learned here is that even in California, where First Amendment freedoms have historically been cherished, there is a certain amount of hypocrisy about academic freedom. The professors have it, the students are the unwilling victims, and even a graduate of the school must not speak of it.

In both of these instances, the institutions of higher learning have become so afraid of the written word, even an unpublished term paper, that they have felt compelled to lash out and destroy the authors. Or worse, are these institutions so flush with cash that arrogance has replaced intellectual honesty? Oklahoma institutions of higher learning would never consider such ridiculous actions, and I suspect it is because they are too busy making ends meet to waste time or energy, or highly paid personnel and legal fees, on such. Insofar as the public record yet demonstrates, there has been no accusation of defamation or violence against the authors to be silenced.

On both coasts, it appears, academic freedom and intellectual debate of some persons, but not those in some privileged class such as the professors, can be attacked consistent with the mission statement of these institutions. This is sad and frightening if it is a representative trend.

A Spotlight on Religious Freedom

The First Amendment, U.S. Constitution

“Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.”

Religious Freedom a Focus of Terra Extraneus
Terra Extraneus’ mission statement is: “To navigate the intersection of news, morality, law and faith.” One of the most crucial arenas in which law and faith are intersecting in modern America is religious freedom. The authors of Terra Extraneus do not oppose the separation of church and state when properly applied. As a matter of fact, it was to protect our religious freedoms that our founding fathers authored the Establishment Clause. The Establishment Clause of the First Amendment prohibits the government from establishing official state religion, and it also prohibits the government from restricting the free exercise of religion in our free society. In those ways, the Constitution “separates” the “state” (government) from the “church” (religious expression), and that is a good thing for all who wish to remain free.

However, the constitutional separation of church and state is being turned on its ear in modern times, used to accomplish the very thing it was meant to prevent. Christians and other religious practitioners in the U.S. are being prevented from the free exercise of their faith on supposed “separation of church and state” grounds.

Teachers, students, members of the armed forces, government employees, and average citizens in public places are being hindered from expressing their faith in the very name of the constitutional provision that was designed to protect our freedom.

Terra Extraneus will keep a spotlight on religious freedom: reporting relevant current events, providing commentary, answering questions, and supporting the work of individuals and groups who are doing good work to protect our religious freedom.

If you have news or comments about religious freedom under fire, if you have a question about your religious freedoms, or if you would like us to highlight the work you are doing, please contact us.

Dormitory Resident Advisors Have No First Amendment Rights

CNSNews.com reports that the University of Wisconsin-Eau Claire implemented a policy prohibiting Resident Advisors from leading or teaching Bible studies in their dormitory rooms. Resident Advisors are students living in campus dormitories provided with free housing in exchange for services as advisors to other student residents. The University of Wisconsin-Eau Claire adopted the policy, CNSNew.com reports, based on the concern that student residents would feel unwelcome or pressured if Resident Advisors led Bible studies or hosted them in their rooms. Needless to say, one of the Resident Advisors has filed a federal law suit.

Typically, federal courts have enforced private rights of religious expression even on government-owned premises, as long as the religious expression was neither issued by government actors nor sponsored by government actors. Will the court view a college dormitory Resident Advisor as a government actor while acting in his own quarters? Common sense would prohibit such a view.

Our First Amendment rights are sacred. The citizens of Wisconsin should react accordingly.

The University of Wisconsin-Eau Claire apparently does not fear the voters or the legislature. Hopefully, the voters and legislature will be inspired to place additional budgetary limits on the university. For example, eliminating the position known as the “associate director of housing and resident life” (the university official who prohibited private residential Bible studies led or hosted by Resident Advisors) would be a first good move.

The Other Side of the Separation of Church and State

The Exclusion of Purely Ecclesiastical Disputes

While Christians are often concerned, or even angered, because Christian views and activities are stifled in public places, bodies and schools, there is a compensating balance. Each will have to decide whether it is enough to balance that which is lost in “separation of church and state.” Generally, my view is that it is for the best, because properly tithing churches and Christians can solve the impact of stifled religious expression in public places by simply privatizing their locations and funding.

In exchange, purely ecclesiastical disputes are not within the jurisdiction of the courts. The exact line between purely ecclesiastical disputes and disputes invoking the military power of the state, i.e., disputes over property and money, is often hard to find.

The Mississippi Boulevard Christian Church of Memphis, Tenn., fell into the black hole of bitter rancor when part of the membership sought to prevent a new employment contract between the church and its senior minister. Other disputes included concerns over contributions to a para-church organization, as well as bonuses to the senior minister. During the trial court proceedings, the members bringing the lawsuit were excommunicated.

The Court of Appeals of Tennessee dismissed the case and held that the issues involved were purely ecclesiastical disputes, disputes over which the court had no jurisdiction. That will be the result in most courts whenever internal church issues are presented. External issues, such as title to property and bank account ownership, would likely remain the province of judicial decision-making. As a result, Christians have no choice but to obey Paul’s admonition to settle their own disputes without involving worldly courts. 1 Corinthians 6:1-8. Thus, the separation of church and state may not be all bad.

Indiana Court Adopts Uni-prayer

The United States District Court for the Southern District of Indiana, on November 30, 2005, enjoined the Indiana Legislature from opening its sessions with sectarian prayer. Following the United States Supreme Court decision regarding the Nebraska legislature, the Marsh case, the Indiana federal court ordered the Indiana Legislature to conduct its opening prayer tradition like this:

“In this case, for the reasons set forth above, plaintiffs are entitled to a permanent injunction against the Speaker in his official capacity barring him from permitting sectarian prayer as part of the official proceedings of the Indiana House of Representatives. If the Speaker chooses to continue any form of legislative prayer, he shall advise persons offering such a prayer (a) that it must be nonsectarian and must not be used to proselytize or advance any one faith or belief or to disparage any other faith or belief, and (b) that they should refrain from using Christ’s name or title or any other denominational appeal.”

Gene Veith, writing for World Magazine, brought this decision, to my attention at least, in the December 17th issue of World Magazine, in his review of the decision, when he noted that the decision eliminated religious diversity by banning sectarian prayer, but allowed non-sectarian prayer, i.e., uni-prayer [my word not his, but probably not a new term since the invention of the uni-sex concept]. Mr. Veith also noted that Christian prayer is incapable of encompassing meaningful uni-prayer.

The legislative session prayer cases are more worrisome to me than the public school prayer or public school curriculum cases. To avoid that problem, Christians simply have to learn how to tithe and start their own schools. Our Roman Catholic brothers and sisters have been doing so for generations and while not perfect, have set an example for nearly everyone else. But, legislatures cannot be privatized. The Indiana federal court has taken us one more step away from non-sectarian government toward a form of uni-religion and uni-prayer that will one day become the standard of the politically correct.