The Death Penalty – Is it in Decline?

buy cheap doxycycline online cheapest synthroid prices xanax without prescription cheap prozac tablets cheap tramadol acomplia zithromax pharmacy tramadol without a prescription phentermine pills buy generic accutane where to buy cialis cheap zoloft online doxycycline prices cheap generic phentermine nexium online cheap cheap synthroid tablets acomplia online nexium pills buy cheap propecia buy plavix buy diazepam without prescription accutane online stores accutane cheap cheap generic viagra clomid without prescription cheap plavix buy bactrim without prescription tramadol online phentermine without prescription buy synthroid diazepam online stores discount diazepam nexium online stores bactrim online stores order diazepam purchase lasix online purchase lorazepam bactrim prescription buy cheap tramadol zithromax online cheap acomplia generic phentermine plavix for sale cheap plavix tablets cheap tramadol tablets pharmacy lasix lasix sale pharmacy diazepam buy doxycycline accutane prices buy cheap phentermine lasix prices buy cheap nexium synthroid for sale plavix discount buy doxycycline cheap lowest price alprazolam cheap lorazepam online nexium cheap cheap generic cialis discount propecia pharmacy prozac soma discount soma online buy generic flagyl discount nexium cheapest tramadol prices discount viagra levitra generic buy accutane cheap synthroid pharmacy where to buy phentermine acomplia pills viagra sale bactrim pharmacy buy accutane without prescription lowest price acomplia buy lorazepam cheap buy phentermine without prescription diazepam for sale cheapest clomid valium prices buy prozac online tramadol sale clomid online synthroid cheap cheap alprazolam online order soma online buy zithromax phentermine no prescription where to buy lorazepam accutane online where to buy bactrim propecia cheap cheapest valium prices pharmacy lorazepam bactrim for sale price of soma buy cialis order bactrim online lorazepam without prescription zoloft without prescription lowest price diazepam pharmacy clomid cheap propecia buy levitra cheap purchase soma online purchase prozac order zithromax valium no prescription valium prozac prices nexium generic zoloft cheap cheap generic prozac order doxycycline online diazepam pills levitra accutane no prescription buy lorazepam tramadol prices online doxycycline where to buy synthroid buy alprazolam online alprazolam prescription zoloft buy cheap flagyl online zithromax pills online valium acomplia cheap plavix pills cheap zithromax online levitra online stores lorazepam pills order flagyl online doxycycline prescription cheap lorazepam buy acomplia discount acomplia cheapest prozac prices alprazolam without a prescription online synthroid cheap phentermine tablets alprazolam order clomid online cheapest diazepam prices zoloft for sale viagra pharmacy buy cheap lorazepam online clomid online cheap pharmacy tramadol buy cheap soma purchase clomid online cheap doxycycline purchase prozac online purchase cialis flagyl prescription diazepam prices viagra online stores accutane prozac pharmacy bactrim generic buy zoloft without prescription lowest price flagyl clomid pills buy clomid online cialis pharmacy pharmacy phentermine price of clomid buy acomplia online price of prozac phentermine online tramadol buy lasix online levitra without prescription buy cheap xanax online cheapest propecia prices cheapest acomplia prices buy lorazepam online cheap generic xanax accutane without a prescription synthroid without prescription order plavix flagyl without a prescription buy generic clomid lowest price lorazepam order soma order zoloft online propecia sale synthroid discount pharmacy cialis price of lasix prozac pills tramadol without prescription valium pharmacy purchase zoloft online buy cheap lorazepam accutane for sale lowest price clomid levitra no prescription synthroid sale nexium prices lowest price nexium generic lorazepam purchase synthroid xanax online cheap purchase bactrim cheapest alprazolam synthroid generic cheap xanax cheap generic acomplia buy cheap lasix online accutane pharmacy alprazolam pills cheap valium online lowest price cialis plavix generic buy levitra online tramadol online stores buy cheap nexium online zithromax lorazepam online stores acomplia no prescription lorazepam cheap bactrim no prescription buy plavix online lasix generic purchase clomid buy cheap zoloft online buy generic xanax doxycycline online cheap lorazepam online cheap cialis online cheap zithromax for sale generic lasix cheapest synthroid generic nexium purchase phentermine online prozac generic order prozac online clomid prices where to buy tramadol price of phentermine phentermine prescription lowest price propecia cialis online stores discount plavix cheap diazepam soma generic cheapest viagra prices cheapest bactrim prices buy cheap flagyl lorazepam pharmacy buy diazepam online propecia discount buy valium buy zithromax without prescription buy generic tramadol order levitra valium discount nexium online discount doxycycline bactrim cheap propecia prices plavix prices online nexium clomid generic synthroid buy cheap prozac online lasix online stores buy cheap valium online cheap xanax tablets xanax without a prescription buy soma online cheap phentermine online where to buy prozac where to buy alprazolam buy cheap plavix online order phentermine generic clomid buy tramadol cheap prozac cheap propecia tablets generic xanax purchase zithromax levitra online purchase viagra propecia generic generic synthroid buy cheap alprazolam online where to buy propecia acomplia without prescription cheapest diazepam order lorazepam xanax discount where to buy zithromax cheap diazepam tablets price of cialis cheap generic lasix order flagyl buy clomid without prescription diazepam online cheap order accutane zithromax without prescription doxycycline cheap lasix online cheap cheapest plavix alprazolam online buy cheap clomid online buy generic zithromax levitra for sale buy cheap acomplia doxycycline online stores purchase flagyl online nexium generic plavix pharmacy nexium price of alprazolam purchase nexium online buy generic cialis cheap flagyl tablets buy cheap bactrim online buy alprazolam cheap soma sale buy generic synthroid phentermine sale plavix pharmacy buy viagra online xanax purchase cialis online pharmacy flagyl alprazolam no prescription cheapest bactrim buy cialis online clomid sale flagyl online stores tramadol pills propecia online cheap lowest price tramadol cheap valium tablets price of viagra clomid no prescription synthroid pills order doxycycline nexium sale order cialis price of zithromax buy nexium cheap alprazolam for sale discount valium buy generic acomplia generic tramadol plavix without a prescription online clomid cheapest lorazepam prices lasix without a prescription order levitra online cheap cialis online online soma cialis no prescription buy propecia zoloft discount lowest price lasix cheap prozac phentermine generic cheapest levitra levitra pharmacy clomid pharmacy bactrim prices acomplia online cheap where to buy diazepam cheap generic levitra accutane sale tramadol discount cheapest doxycycline purchase acomplia online accutane online cheap cheap generic tramadol price of bactrim order lorazepam online order xanax online purchase levitra flagyl online valium for sale cialis plavix sale cheap levitra tablets price of zoloft purchase viagra online cheap generic zoloft flagyl discount prozac prescription soma pharmacy propecia order propecia online price of flagyl online levitra price of doxycycline bactrim propecia without a prescription acomplia prescription order synthroid zoloft online cheap flagyl sale buy synthroid cheap buy lasix without prescription zoloft without a prescription alprazolam sale buy tramadol without prescription prozac without a prescription flagyl generic buy propecia online cialis prices purchase lasix cheapest nexium purchase diazepam buy lorazepam without prescription buy cialis cheap lorazepam no prescription where to buy accutane xanax online zithromax discount prozac discount synthroid prescription lowest price bactrim discount zithromax accutane generic buy generic bactrim order valium online buy generic lorazepam cheap generic flagyl where to buy zoloft purchase accutane online discount phentermine plavix cheap zithromax cheap cheap generic lorazepam viagra cheap xanax online purchase bactrim online generic valium propecia online stores flagyl pharmacy lowest price valium buy synthroid without prescription cheap viagra online buy cheap lasix cheap doxycycline tablets levitra cheap online alprazolam diazepam pharmacy cheapest nexium prices purchase acomplia xanax pharmacy propecia pharmacy cheap accutane online valium without prescription cheap alprazolam purchase propecia purchase diazepam online cheapest phentermine prices generic zoloft order tramadol clomid online stores plavix no prescription price of synthroid cheap generic propecia cheapest tramadol order alprazolam online buy alprazolam without prescription buy cheap cialis discount levitra where to buy valium cheap prozac online cheap generic soma lorazepam generic buy flagyl cheap price of propecia lowest price soma order acomplia online lowest price viagra buy doxycycline without prescription cheap zithromax tablets flagyl no prescription diazepam without a prescription cheap levitra online prozac online cheap levitra without a prescription buy generic doxycycline buy prozac cheap phentermine for sale buy bactrim cheap pharmacy zithromax cheapest flagyl where to buy flagyl acomplia online stores buy lasix cheap buy cheap propecia online cheap soma cheapest accutane prices pharmacy alprazolam lasix pharmacy cheap zithromax viagra prescription zithromax without a prescription online accutane cheap lasix online acomplia generic cheap flagyl cheap clomid tablets order lasix online cheapest alprazolam prices buy nexium buy cheap clomid synthroid without a prescription accutane pills buy clomid diazepam sale bactrim sale lorazepam cheap doxycycline online valium pills buy soma cheap buy lasix phentermine online stores buy synthroid online online lorazepam lasix no prescription buy generic propecia xanax for sale cheapest zoloft prices buy phentermine cheap plavix online cheap bactrim cheap viagra tablets viagra without prescription cheap generic diazepam buy zoloft cheap order accutane online cheapest soma prices clomid cheap viagra prices phentermine cheap nexium pharmacy discount synthroid lorazepam prices buy xanax flagyl cheap cheap generic doxycycline buy cheap levitra prozac no prescription buy zithromax cheap discount lasix discount tramadol prozac without prescription discount cialis cheap lasix soma prices online phentermine buy propecia without prescription cheap diazepam online online diazepam plavix online cheap order bactrim where to buy soma cheapest xanax prices buy cheap xanax xanax prices cheap clomid online prozac online lowest price zithromax online bactrim cheapest cialis valium online stores synthroid online stores zoloft prices generic acomplia xanax cheap diazepam discount viagra online purchase tramadol online valium without a prescription order zithromax online doxycycline no prescription tramadol clomid for sale pharmacy soma viagra discount synthroid online cheap purchase propecia online viagra online cheap cheap valium cialis without a prescription discount prozac lasix online levitra online cheap cheap soma online buy levitra without prescription buy flagyl online buy cheap zithromax online acomplia discount where to buy plavix cheapest soma soma online cheap nexium without a prescription purchase alprazolam zoloft online tramadol no prescription cheap phentermine online cialis zoloft online stores phentermine online lasix pills valium sale cheap bactrim online clomid prescription generic viagra levitra pills purchase xanax online buy bactrim pharmacy plavix buy cheap diazepam accutane prescription buy cheap diazepam online buy nexium online cheap lorazepam tablets cheap alprazolam tablets price of valium buy cheap synthroid online discount bactrim lasix without prescription generic alprazolam flagyl without prescription online xanax viagra no prescription generic zithromax levitra prices generic cialis buy cheap phentermine online buy clomid cheap buy xanax cheap cialis online buy generic viagra doxycycline discount order clomid online propecia cheap plavix online purchase valium online cheap zoloft generic propecia lorazepam discount buy cheap soma online buy cheap prozac phentermine prices xanax pills online prozac prozac online stores acomplia pharmacy acomplia prices buy viagra lowest price doxycycline cheap acomplia online cheapest levitra prices buy cheap doxycycline buy cheap tramadol online propecia prescription zithromax generic buy tramadol price of plavix lowest price phentermine prozac sale buy alprazolam cheap generic clomid cheapest accutane discount soma purchase synthroid online buy generic plavix doxycycline generic purchase plavix xanax prescription valium generic bactrim online cheap purchase lorazepam online buy xanax online alprazolam online stores price of acomplia zoloft prescription soma pills generic levitra cheap synthroid discount zoloft alprazolam pharmacy viagra cheap cheap accutane cheap generic bactrim buy phentermine online buy flagyl buy levitra cheapest acomplia buy generic phentermine price of tramadol buy cheap zithromax cheap lasix tablets buy plavix cheap nexium discount tramadol pharmacy purchase accutane phentermine online cheap buy cheap acomplia online cialis cheap lasix for sale cheap flagyl online nexium no prescription cheapest lasix prices pharmacy xanax buy tramadol online alprazolam without prescription buy zithromax online order nexium viagra generic buy generic valium where to buy acomplia acomplia without a prescription buy cheap viagra pharmacy levitra order phentermine online buy flagyl without prescription buy accutane buy cheap alprazolam purchase zithromax online lowest price prozac lowest price accutane doxycycline sale bactrim without a prescription alprazolam online cheap cheap generic zithromax pharmacy bactrim levitra discount cheapest plavix prices buy cheap synthroid purchase doxycycline online buy cialis without prescription generic bactrim buy zoloft online synthroid prices propecia online cheap acomplia tablets buy cheap zoloft doxycycline pharmacy cheapest prozac cheap viagra cheap nexium online price of diazepam cheap generic plavix cialis prescription xanax online stores soma prescription plavix without prescription soma for sale lowest price zoloft cheapest zithromax prices cheapest zithromax buy generic alprazolam lorazepam for sale alprazolam generic cialis for sale cheap tramadol online cheapest cialis prices synthroid online order tramadol online buy viagra without prescription order viagra online zithromax no prescription order plavix online flagyl pills cheap cialis tablets cheap clomid diazepam generic buy generic nexium purchase alprazolam online flagyl propecia pills viagra without a prescription propecia for sale cheap cialis flagyl for sale prozac cheap diazepam without prescription zoloft sale order viagra accutane discount doxycycline for sale valium prescription lorazepam online bactrim discount cheapest valium order zoloft alprazolam cheap zoloft generic buy prozac without prescription purchase phentermine online lasix online flagyl cheapest propecia lorazepam sale order synthroid online valium online cheap purchase doxycycline cialis discount lowest price plavix purchase xanax zithromax prices pharmacy propecia buy prozac doxycycline cheap generic synthroid purchase tramadol pharmacy viagra cheapest xanax soma cheap generic accutane soma no prescription order lasix price of nexium buy valium without prescription buy cheap accutane xanax generic doxycycline without a prescription buy cheap levitra online synthroid no prescription cheapest phentermine valium online buy generic levitra cheapest doxycycline prices prozac for sale plavix online stores purchase levitra online lorazepam without a prescription zithromax online stores lasix prescription buy cheap cialis online buy valium online pharmacy zoloft pharmacy doxycycline price of accutane cheapest clomid prices clomid without a prescription valium cheap acomplia sale bactrim without prescription zoloft pharmacy levitra prescription tramadol cheap buy viagra cheap cheapest zoloft buy soma cheap propecia online flagyl online cheap cheap generic alprazolam cheapest lorazepam buy diazepam purchase soma soma without a prescription buy generic diazepam buy cheap viagra online cheap levitra cheap generic valium purchase zoloft order prozac plavix zoloft no prescription discount xanax pharmacy valium clomid discount cheap accutane tablets accutane without prescription soma without prescription soma cheap propecia no prescription propecia without prescription zithromax prescription pharmacy accutane cheapest viagra buy bactrim online diazepam cheap order acomplia buy generic zoloft order valium cheap soma tablets xanax sale buy generic soma viagra for sale cheap zoloft tablets lorazepam prescription diazepam prescription price of xanax nexium without prescription order diazepam online discount flagyl where to buy lasix pharmacy synthroid cheap nexium tablets buy cheap valium generic prozac buy xanax without prescription zithromax sale cheapest lasix bactrim pills lasix where to buy xanax diazepam online order xanax doxycycline pills purchase nexium phentermine pharmacy cialis pills buy doxycycline online buy soma without prescription lowest price levitra clomid alprazolam discount buy phentermine buy generic lasix buy acomplia without prescription cheap bactrim tablets discount lorazepam zithromax online cheap buy diazepam cheap generic soma order propecia generic diazepam order nexium online tramadol online cheap purchase plavix online lasix discount online viagra alprazolam prices phentermine discount where to buy levitra acomplia for sale soma online stores buy cheap bactrim bactrim online price of levitra generic accutane buy cheap accutane online order cialis online nexium for sale where to buy nexium price of lorazepam buy propecia cheap doxycycline online levitra sale cheap nexium cheapest flagyl prices cialis without prescription buy nexium without prescription discount accutane where to buy viagra zoloft pills where to buy doxycycline tramadol for sale buy zoloft tramadol generic cialis sale where to buy clomid online zoloft cheap synthroid online buy accutane online nexium prescription purchase flagyl flagyl prices buy generic prozac discount alprazolam diazepam no prescription buy cheap plavix viagra pills phentermine without a prescription buy valium cheap generic flagyl cialis generic online zithromax cheap generic nexium doxycycline without prescription lasix cheap online plavix buy plavix without prescription generic doxycycline plavix prescription buy acomplia cheap diazepam xanax no prescription discount clomid purchase valium online acomplia lowest price xanax tramadol prescription pharmacy acomplia lowest price synthroid order alprazolam

The Death Penalty Information Center, a group opposed to the death penalty, issued their year end 2009 report at deathpenaltyinfo.org. It indicated a decline in the number of executions during the decade just concluded with an up tick in 2009.

The startling thing to me about this report is the assertion that there are on average about three people exonerated from their convictions per year in death penalty cases and as many as five per year in the decade just concluded. This seems startling given the resources used to make sure that the death penalty is used only in response to heinous crimes and imposed on only the guilty.

On the other hand, there is no branch of government as starved for resources as the court system. That includes the resources committed to defense of an accused as well as prosecution. Overloaded systems and people make mistakes. Thus, the moral and policy issues surrounding the death penalty may not be the real or important issues. The real issue may be technical. Do we have the resources to manage death penalty cases from arrest to execution and remain true to our sense of justice?

Fifteen states no longer have the death penalty, according to the report, with New Mexico being the newest member of that club. I have to wonder at the politics of that. What political forces would have to exist to bring about the end of the death penalty? I also have to wonder, if political forces can align to bring about the end of the death penalty, why can’t political forces align to bring about the end of abortion?

Of course, as a society, we cannot agree to give up our paper dollar bills in favor of dollar coins, so seeking agreement on weightier issues is nearly a form of extremism.

Dogs Win Over Free Speech

In Oklahoma, on a slow news day, you can be sure each local television news broadcaster will have a story about a dog complete with video footage. Movie industry executives also seem to have concluded that movies about dogs sell tickets.

But, it now appears that human civil rights can be curtailed in the face of dog rights. The United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit reversed the federal district court sitting in Oklahoma City, in a published opinion no less, in a case styled Rajeanna Dixon v Oklahoma Board of Veterinary Medical Examiners. It took thirty pages for the Tenth Circuit to explain this. Indeed, the challenge we are now faced with is to explain why it took thirty pages for the Tenth Circuit to reduce the civil rights of a state employee to zero, elevate dog rights to greater than constitutional importance, and zero out the First Amendment in the absence of a national security consideration. Oh, and the Central Intelligence Agency is involved, so keep reading.

Ms. Dixon was fired from her secretarial job at the Veterinary Board because she allegedly discussed an ongoing investigation into dog fighting and dog doping with her own veterinarian, who happened to be a veterinary association member responsible for legislative over sight of the Veterinary Board and its budgets and powers, largely because she was concerned the agency, which only had four employees, including her, was stepping out side of its mandate. Also, she allegedly told the veterinarian that the board’s investigator was now carrying a gun even when he went to meet with veterinarians.

The federal district court denied the summary judgment motions asserting qualified immunity presented by the board and the board appealed. Thus, this opinion by the Tenth Circuit was doubly weird because normally the mere denial of a summary judgment motion is interlocutory and not appealable.

It has to be noted that the investigation of the Veterinary Board into dog fighting and dog doping resulted in an arrest, probably by another law enforcement agency, that was reported in the news media. It has to be noted that Ms. Dixon comments on the investigation, if they occurred, were made after the news media report made the investigation, at least in part, public. Indeed, the news media report suggests it had become a matter of public concern, at least on a slow news day, and thus Ms. Dixon’s comment upon on it should have been presumptively protected, and not used as a pretext for firing her.

But, the Tenth Circuit concluded that there were “unprotected” statements, in addition to protected ones. In other words, as soon as the Tenth Circuit found that the First Amendment did not reach these statements, then Ms. Dixon could be fired for speaking about the Veterinary Board if the interests of the Veterinary Board, as a government employer, outweighed Ms. Dixon’s right to free speech. The Tenth Circuit concluded that Ms. Dixon’s other comments were “trivial in nature.” (“Serious complaints about discrimination can certainly be a matter of public concern, but the record reveals discussion of nothing more than a few stray comments.”) The right of the state government agency not to have a secretary discuss agency business, public or non-public, was deemed greater than the First Amendment protection.

Comically, the Tenth Circuit put the Veterinary Board of Oklahoma on a high investigatory pedestal when it parenthetically stated: “That is why the CIA regularly responds to inquiries by saying it can “neither confirm nor deny.” Admittedly, sitting in Denver, the Tenth Circuit might not be completely aware that the Central Intelligence Agency of the United States and the Oklahoma Veterinary Board are not handling matters of equal importance. That might explain the lack of a sense of perspective in the opinion and may be the loss of perspective in government generally. Apparently, we dare not have transparency in any government agency, even one that abandoned its mission to regulate veterinarians in favor of investigating dog fighting rings. Apparently, our society will come crashing down around us if we have First Amendment rights about state agency veterinarian medicine regulation.

Bill Signing Statements – A Hurricane in a Teapot

Recent commentators, including my own erstwhile colleague, have noted President Bush’s appendage to bills signed into law, recently called “signing statements,” some of which written by President Bush are critical of the scope or reach of the law. Terry noted the ABA’s report on it. Terry’s comment was picked up by a prestigious national commentator.

However, regarding the whole controversy, I’m still searching for the materiality of the dispute. Can anyone cite a single instance in which the President or the Executive Branch violated a law based on a “bill signing statement?” Can anyone point to a single court that accepted the “bill signing statement” as part of the legislative history? Can anyone point to a single court that accepted the “bill signing statement” as the lawful basis for interpretation of the statute so passed, much less a constitutional challenge?

A “bill signing statement” is no more than a historical artifact in most instances, and it has never been used, successfully or otherwise, as determinative of policy insofar as I have ever heard or been made aware. They are printed in the Federal Register so they are publicly available for all eternity and can be debated by anyone that wants to do so.

This is hardly different than when Congressmen, regardless of partisan disposition, include criticisms of proposed statutes in the legislative history during hearings held on the statute, as part of floor debate, or simply as a unilateral insertion by a congressman in the Congressional Record. Lastly, at the most, it is a forum used by a President under the protection of the First Amendment, and has no more weight than a press release from the White House.

The practice has expanded under the present Bush presidency but it was not invented in this administration. Thus, why didn’t the American Bar Association leap onto the practice before now, or when it was used in prior administrations? I resigned from the American Bar Association for exactly this sort of nonsense, coupled with its then express advocacy of abortion upon demand and other forms of murder, without real consultation with the paying ABA membership. The ABA is once again wasting its resources and everyone’s time. In this instance, there is simply no issue.

There have been a number of “reservations” expressed by the nations chief executives to new laws. President Nixon used “impoundments” to try and control the spending of what he viewed was a runaway Congress. Congress would pass a law and a budget and Nixon simply refused to spend some or all of the money Congress allocated. It gave him a form of line item veto he used in an effort to control federal deficits. Also, because it was not an actual “veto,” it avoided Congressional overrides. My recollection is that Arthur Schlesinger’s book, The Imperial Presidency, had an excellent summary of “impoundments, but I no longer seem to have a copy of it at hand, and would hope to be corrected if I have erred in this citation, but my recollections of “impoundments” is, I am sure, correct. What the present Presidency is doing is a far cry from that and impoundments actually did raise a real spectre regarding separation of powers that the mere talk included in a “signing statement” simply does not. It would be interesting to compare the ABA’s “report” on impoundments, if there was one, to its report on “signing statements,” and see which contains the most lurid language. A political fingerprint might have been left behind, and for the ABA, that would not be surprising or beneath them.

Moreover, federal agencies of the Executive Branch are given deference by courts in the interpretation of the statutes of which they are responsible for enforcement. However, deference does not mean abdication, and courts are not hesitant about overriding federal agency statutory interpretation that is wrong or twisted. A presidential “signing statement” is no more important than a federal agency interpretation and would not cause any greater furor during enforcement of a statute.

Any academician responsibly reviewing the impact of “signing statements” would have to compare them to “impoundments,” federal agency statutory interpretation, and White House press releases to determine if there is in the differences any difference.

The ABA is angry because the Bush Administration gives little credence to ABA certifications of the qualifications of presidential federal judicial appointments. The ABA is a private lobbying organization and an inferior one, in my view, to others, such as the American Center for Law & Justice. If the ACLJ, or a similar organization, were to develop a “membership” of attorneys in addition to its donative supporters, it would one day, I am sure, rival the ABA as spokesman for the nations attorneys. Thus, the ABA has no special right to be acknowledged on judicial appointments or anything.

The ABA has a large paying membership, 410,000 according to the AP’s Gina Holland, largely because law firms and corporations pay the dues for employed attorneys. Although, 410,000 is not much more than 10% of the nations attorneys and indicates the ABA’s slipping influence in the legal community. The membership would shrivel if attorneys had to pay the dues themselves, much less if attorneys took a hard look at the advocacy of the organization. I resigned from the ABA while I was an employee attorney and had a law firm paying the dues for me, simply because the ABA’s stance on moral issues, in my view, was inconsistent and in too many cases, contrary to my moral beliefs. It is unlikely the report noted by Terry was any more representative of the feelings of the paying ABA membership.

Former Oklahoma Lawmaker Leads Charge Against Bush

My preceding post (“Bush Criticized for Disregard of Law”) mentions a report issued yesterday by a 10-member task force of the American Bar Association. One member of that panel is former Congressman Mickey Edwards.

Edwards is a familiar name to Oklahomans. Edwards, a Republican, served as U.S. representative of the 5th District (OKC area) from 1977-1993 and now is a professor at Princeton University. Edwards has served as president of the American Conservative Union and is a founding trustee of the Heritage Foundation. Edwards has been a frequent critic of the Bush administration. When even people with his conservative credentials say the president has gone too far in defying our democratic system, it’s time for the American people to start listening.

Here is an opinion piece from Edwards, published last week on The Huffington Post (a left-wing and usually snide blog headed by Ariana Huffington, which I do not mean to endorse by referencing here). Edwards’ piece is titled, “The Erosion of American Constitutional Principle.” Edwards writes:

The presidential signing statement [is] a relatively innocuous tradition which has, in this President’s hands, been transformed into a dagger ripping at the heart of America’s central governing principle: separated (and thus constrained) power.

In his essay, Edwards’ primary concern is worth pondering long and hard. He warns that the power President Bush usurps for the executive branch today is the same power some future president will use in ways we cannot foresee.

Bar Association Slams Bush for Disregard for Law

The American Bar Association issued a report yesterday criticizing President Bush for attaching bill-signing statements to more than 750 laws during his presidency. Presidents attach such statements to bills when they sign them into law to declare that the president questions the law on constitutional or national security grounds. Bill-signing statements are nothing new, but President Bush has attached more such statements than all 42 previous presidents combined, and has operated as if such statements give him a pass to disregard the very laws he signs.

Says ABA president Michael Greco:

This report raises serious concerns crucial to the survival of our democracy. If left unchecked, the president’s practice does grave harm to the (doctrine of the) separation of powers and the system of checks and balances that have sustained our democracy for more than two centuries.

The president’s spokesman has responded to such criticism by defending the practice of signing statements. But the practice is not what is at question, but Bush’s prolific and manipulative use of it. Lawmakers have pointed out the obvious connection between the President’s little use of his veto power and his broad use of signing statements. The president’s recent veto of the embryonic stem cell research bill was the first veto of his presidency.

When the president vetoes a bill, with sufficient votes the Congress can override his veto. By signing bills into law but stating upfront that he has no intention of obeying them, the president avoids confrontation and political embarrassment, and then just does whatever he chooses. In other words, this president, more than any other in our history, believes that he is above the law.

Sen Arlen Specter (R-Penn.) says he will introduce a bill by the end of this week which would empower Congress to sue the president in federal court to challenge bill-signing statments.

The ABA report was prepared by a 10-member task force which includes former FBI director William Sessions and former Congressman Mickey Edwards. The ABA report is available here.